|
What's
New in Male Infertility Treatment
|
Cornell
University
Weill Medical College
Cornell Institute for Reproductive Medicine
Center for
Male Reproductive Medicine and Microsurgery
Directors
Marc Goldstein,
M.D. Marc Goldstein, M.D., F.A.C.S. is Professor of Reproductive Medicine
and Urology at Weill Medical College of Cornell University, Co-Executive
Director of the Cornell Institute for Reproductive Medicine and Co-Director
of the Center for Male Reproductive Medicine and Microsurgery at the New
York Presbyterian Hospital-Weill Medical College of Cornell University.
He is Staff Scientist with the Population Council's Center for Biomedical
Research, located on the campus of Rockefeller University.
Peter N.
SchlePeter N. Schlegel, M.D., F.A.C.S. is an Associate Professor of Urology
and Vice Chairman for Clinical Affairs in Urology at The Weill Medical
College of Cornell University, a Staff Scientist at The Population Council,
Center for Biomedical Research, a Visiting Associate Physician at The
Rockefeller University Hospital, and an Associate Attending Surgeon at
The New York Hospital.gel, M.D.
Anatomy and
Physiology of Male Reproduction
1. HORMONAL
CONSIDERATIONS
2. TESTICULAR ANATOMY
3. SEMINIFEROUS TUBULES
4. THE EPIDIDYMIS
Compared to other species, human males have relatively poor sperm producing
capacity and human testicular function is very sensitive to a wide variety
of environmental insults. This may be related to the human (upright) posture
and hydrostatic pressure on venous testicular outflow, or other unknown
factors, but it is necessary for clinicians to be aware of the high incidence
of subfertility in men. Perhaps it is a reflection of the incredible ability
of humans to adapt the environment to promote their own survival or the
expectation that fertility should be nearly spontaneous, but many human
couples seek evaluation for infertility. The human male reproductive system
includes the hypothalamic-pituitary-testis axis as well as the epididymis,
vas deferens, seminal vesicles, prostate and urethra. Production of spermatozoa
requires approximately 3 months from the initial mitotic divisions through
the myriad changes readying sperm for ejaculation and fertilization. Highlights
of this transformation include (1) the unique environment created within
the testis for spermatogenesis to occur; (2) preservation of a set of
stem cells relatively resistant to external injury and able to produce
rapidly proliferating germ cells destined to become spermatozoa; (3) meiosis,
that results in formation of the haploid gamete; and (4) the dramatic
differentiation of the prospective gamete in a form that is specialized
to transport chromosomal material in a structure ideally suited for transit
of the female reproductive tract. The spermatozoon resulting from this
complex process assumes its final shape and size in the testis. In the
normal state, it also acquires the ability to fertilize as well as a capacity
for motility in the epididymis. Unfortunately, the mechanisms by which
the epididymis exerts these changes on the traversing spermatozoon and
the actions of the human reproductive tract after relief of chronic obstruction
remain largely unknown.
1. HORMONAL
CONSIDERATIONS
An appropriate hormonal milieu must exist for the reproductive organs
to produce, mature and transport the highly specialized male gamete to
the ejaculatory duct. The entire system of hormone balance is initiated
by the pulsatile hypothalamic release of GnRH ( gonadotropin-releasing
hormone). Pituitary LH ( luteinizing hormone) secretion is determined
by GnRH pulses from the hypothalamus, that occur approximately every two
hours and are carried via a venous portal network to the pituitary. This
hypothalamohypophyseal portal connection allows an exact synchrony of
GnRH and LH pulse secretion. FSH ( follicle-stimulating hormone) secretion
is also stimulated by GnRH, but FSH and LH are differentially regulated
by hormonal and other factors that are poorly understood. The factors
influencing FSH secretion are produced by Sertoli cells and other components
of the testis that probably includes peptides of the inhibin and activin
families. Within the testis, LH stimulates Leydig cell synthesis of testosterone.
Testosterone production by the Leydig cell provides locally high intratesticular
concentrations of this hormone that stimulates spermatogenesis. Testosterone
concentrations in peripheral blood of men change dramatically during the
life cycle. Testosterone reaches a maximum concentration during the second
or third decade of life, then reaches a plateau, and declines thereafter.
Additionally, annual and daily rhythms in testosterone concentration occur,
typically with a testosterone peak in the early morning. Other, irregular
fluctuations in testosterone concentration may also be detectable in peripheral
blood. Testosterone is normally aromatized in peripheral tissue to estrogens.
Excessive testosterone levels, associated with gonadotropin, clomiphene
citrate or flutamide treatment, may paradoxically result in increased
feminization from conversion of androgens to estrogens by aromatase. Similarly,
increased aromatase activity is associated with alcoholism and chronic
liver disease, as well as testis tumors.Accurate clinical assessment of
the pituitary gonadotropins LH and FSH must take into account their pulsatile
release. During clinical research studies, three serum samples are obtained,
one every 30 minutes, and the sera pooled for accurate determination of
mean gonadotropin levels. This process is usually not necessary in clinical
practice, but the clinician should be aware of the potential for LH and
FSH peaks to be measured in a single gonadotropin determination, and perform
repeat evaluation if LH and FSH hormone levels are both elevated. Testosterone
levels may be decreased in the late afternoon or evening. Interpretation
of serum testosterone levels should take the diurnal secretion of this
hormone into account. Prolactin, another pituitary hormone, may affect
fertility by decreasing LH production, resulting in a decrease in testosterone
and subsequently, decreased libido. The release of prolactin is mediated
by dopamine, and the dopamine antagonist bromocriptine will ameliorate
the antifertility effects of hyperprolactinemia.Testosterone is converted
intracellularly within most androgen-sensitive organs to dihydrotestosterone.
Function of the prostate, seminal vesicles, vas deferens, and other sex
accessory organs are all androgen-dependent. The degree to which partial
androgen deprivation in the hypogonadal man affects the function of these
organs is unknown. Furthermore, the effects of "low-normal"
serum testosterone levels on these organs and a man's fertility potential
are unknown. Abnormally elevated serum testosterone levels are peripherally
converted by the aromatase enzyme to estrogens. In addition, chromosomal
abnormalities such as Klinefelter's syndrome(xxy), and some testicular
tumors have elevated aromatase levels. Some obese patients may also have
increased aromatase activity, since aromatase levels are high in adipose
tissue, as well as fat. Therefore, hormonal evaluation of the infertile
man should include determination of serum LH, FSH, testosterone and prolactin.
For men with clinical gynecomastia, serum estradiol should be measured.
2. TESTICULAR
ANATOMY
The human testis is an ovoid mass that lies within the scrotum. The average
testicular volume is 20 cc in healthy young men and decreases in elderly
men. In Asian men, testes tend to be smaller. Normal longitudinal length
of the testis is approximately 4.5 to 5.1 cm. The testicular parenchyma
is surrounded by a capsule containing blood vessels, smooth muscle fibers
and nerve fibers sensitive to pressure. The functional role of the testicular
capsule is unknown, but may relate to movement of fluid out through the
rete testis or control of blood flow to the testis. The testis contains
seminiferous tubules and interstitial cells. The tubules are segregated
into regions by connective tissue septa. The seminiferous tubules are
long V-shaped tubules, both ends of which usually terminate in the rete
testis. Measurement of testicular size is critical in the evaluation of
the infertile man, since seminiferous tubules (the spermatogenetic region
of the testis) occupy approximately 80% of testicular volume. So, a rough
estimate of spermatogenic cell capacity is provided by assessment of testicular
size. Testicular consistency is also of value in determining fertility
capacity. A soft testis is likely to reflect degenerating or shrunken
spermatogenic components within the seminiferous tubules. The seminiferous
tubules drain toward the central superior and posterior regions of the
testis, the rete testis, that has a flat cuboidal epithelium. The rete
coalesces in the superior portion of the testis, just anterior to the
testicular vessels, to form 5-10 efferent ductules. These efferent ducts
leave the testis and travel a short distance to enter the head, or caput
region of the epididymis. The efferent ducts coalesce in a somewhat variable
pattern within the caput epididymis to form a single epididymal tubule.The
artery to the testis is specialized in that it is highly coiled and intimately
associated with a network of anastomotic veins that form the pampiniform
plexus. The counterflowing vessels are separated only by the thickness
of their vascular wall in some areas. This vascular arrangement facilitates
the exchange of heat and small molecules, including testosterone. The
transport of testosterone is a concentration-limited, passive diffusion
process in men. The counter-current exchange of heat in the spermatic
cord provides blood to the testis that is 2 to 4 °C lower than rectal
temperature in the normal individual. A loss of the temperature differential
is associated with testicular dysfunction in humans with idiopathic infertility,
as well as men with varicocele or cryptorchidism. Whether elevated testicular
temperature causes or is simply a reflection of testicular dysfunction
is unknown. Only the association between elevated testicular temperature
and seminiferous failure have been demonstrated. In the distal inguinal
canal, 50% of men will have a single testicular artery identifiable under
l0 x power magnification dissection of the cord, with 30% of men having
two arteries and 20% with three arteries.The venous system is somewhat
unique because the spermatic veins are thin-walled, poorly muscularized,
and lack effective valves except at the inflow points into the inferior
vena cava or the renal vein. The right spermatic vein usually drains into
the vena cava. The left spermatic vein drains into the left renal vein.
The renal vein on the left side is thought to have a higher intraluminal
pressure because the vein is compressed as it passes between the superior
mesenteric artery and the aorta. This "nutcracker effect" may
impair flow through the left renal and spermatic veins, especially in
young men with limited retroperitoneal fat. The differential anatomy of
the left and right spermatic veins is thought to explain, at least in
part, the higher prevalence of varicoceles on the left side. The exact
mechanism by which varicoceles cause infertility is unknown. In animal
models, varicoceles are associated with increased blood flow to the testis
and increased interstitial fluid in the testis. These two findings may
impair regulation of testicular temperature and decrease intratesticular
concentrations of testosterone or other local factors important for spermatogenesis.
3. SEMINIFEROUS
TUBULES
The seminiferous tubules provide a unique environment for the production
of germ cells. The structures involved in this process include germinal
elements and supporting cells. The supporting cells include the peritubular
cells of the basement membrane and the Sertoli cells. The germinal elements
comprise a population of epithelial cells, including a slowly dividing
primitive stem cell population, the rapidly proliferating spermatogonia,
spermatocytes undergoing meiosis, and the metamorphosing spermatids. The
seminiferous tubule also produces an environment known as "the blood-testis
barrier". The testis is unique in that the differentiating germ cells
are potentially antigenic, and recognizable as foreign; however, little
immunological reaction is usually detectable within the testis.Developmentally,
the testis develops from the undifferentiated gonad. These primitive germ
cells are referred to as gonocytes after the gonad differentiates into
a testis by forming seminiferous cords. At this time, the gonocytes are
located in a central position within the seminiferous cords. They are
subsequently classified as spermatogonia after the gonocytes have migrated
to the periphery of the tubule. From birth to approximately 7 years of
life, there appears to be very little morphological change within the
human testis. From 7 to 9 years of life, mitotic activity of gonocytes
is detectable, with spermatogonia populating the base of the seminiferous
tubule in numbers equal to those of the Sertoli cells. There appears to
be little further morphological change in spermatogonia until spermatogenesis
begins at the time of puberty. Further information regarding the maturation
of gonocytes and their migration to the base of the seminiferous tubule,
including the factors that may be responsible for these changes, may provide
greater insight into the effects of cryptorchidism on fertility and impact
on the appropriate timing of intervention for treatment of cryptorchidism.
4. THE
EPIDIDYMIS
Spermatozoa in the unobstructed testis are not motile and are incapable
of fertilizing ova. Spermatozoa become functional gametes only after they
migrate through the epididymis and undergo an additional maturation process,
thereby acquiring the capacities for both progressive motility and fertility.
The function of the obstructed epididymis and its effects on maturation
of spermatozoa may be very different from what is observed in the unobstructed
state. Anatomically, the epididymis can be divided into three regions:
the caput, the corpus, and the cauda epididymis. However, these anatomical
divisions have been defined based on findings in animals, not in humans.
The human epididymal epithelium is relatively homogeneous as viewed under
the microscope, and grossly, the epididymis does not have the same distinct
gross anatomical subdivisions that are easily seen in the rat, rabbit
and other animals. Unfortunately, there is little information available
regarding the functional diversity of these three regions of the human
epididymis. The data that exist on human epididymal function are almost
entirely derived from observations of men after relief of chronic epididymal
obstruction.In humans, the epididymis receives its blood supply from two
sources: branches of the testicular as well as the deferential vessels
that travel along the vas deferens. Clinically, the blood supply becomes
important after a vasectomy with interruption of the vasal vessels. At
the time of vasectomy reversal, the testicular side of the vas deferens
is then supplied by branches off the testicular vessels, which travel
either through collaterals, or along the entire length of the epididymis.
Similarly, if division of the vasal vessels occurs accidentally during
vasography, and a secondary obstruction to the vas deferens (and vasal
vessels) is found and addressed in the groin, then the intervening segment
of vas deferens can be totally devascularized. The viability of the vas
should be considered prior to vaso-vasostomy in this situation.Observations
by Silber regarding the fertility of men who have undergone bilateral
vasal anastomosis to the vasa efferentia, indicate that in the obstructed
human male reproductive tract, some sperm may acquire motility and fertilizing
ability without passing through the epididymis. Although not absolutely
required for male fertility, the functional importance of the human epididymis
is strongly supported by several other observations regarding men who
have undergone intervention for the relief of chronic epididymal obstruction.
In 1990, Silber reported fertility results for men who underwent vasoepididymostomy
at the level of either the caput or corpus epididymis. For both groups
of men, the patency rate was approximately 70%. For men who underwent
anastomosis at the corpus level, 72% of men achieved pregnancy with their
partners, whereas only 43% of men were able to impregnate their wives
after vasoepididymostomy at the caput level. Therefore, the presence of
a longer length of epididymis appears to promote fertility after relief
of chronic obstruction. Our studies in men with congenital absence of
the vas deferens or other surgically unreconstructable obstruction of
the vas have indicated that the longer the segment of epididymis present,
the greater the likelihood of pregnancy with sperm obtained from these
men. Almost all of the information regarding human epididymal function
are derived from observations of men who have undergone surgical reversal
of long term reproductive tract obstruction. The results of several published
observations of men with unobstructed reproductive tracts was compiled
by Bedford. As indicated (in NY Acad Sci 541: 284-291, 1988), the fertility
potential of sperm from the caput region of the obstructed human epididymis
is minimal.The exact fate of unejaculated epididymal spermatozoa in humans
is also unknown. Some sperm have been documented to be phagocytosed by
macrophages in the epididymis, and sperm have been detected in urine.
However, the mechanisms by which quantitative clearance of sperm occurs
from men during periods of sexual abstinence is unknown.In normal, unobstructed
systems, the majority of spermatozoa taken from the vasa efferentia and
diluted in a physiologic solution are immotile or exhibit only weak tail
movements. These observations in the unobstructed human epididymis are
very different from what is seen after relief of chronic epididymal obstruction.
Our observations confirm those of several investigators, that, although
the motility of ejaculated spermatozoa is initially poor following vaso-epididymostomy
at the level of the caput epididymis, sperm motility may improve greatly
up to 1 1/2 years after vasoepididymostomy. These findings suggest that
following vasoepididymostomy the caput epididymis or vas deferens may
undergo compensatory adaption over time and support sperm motility maturation
despite exposure of sperm to a shortened length of epididymis. In animal
models, vasal obstruction causes changes in the intrinsic motility of
fluid through the epididymal lumen. These changes are not completely reversed
by technically successful vasovasostomy. It is not known what effect the
apparent change in epididymal contractility may have on epididymal function.Studies
on laboratory animals describe many changes that occur to sperm during
epididymal transit. These include a change in net sperm surface charge,
addition and alteration of membrane proteins, alterations in sperm lectin-binding
properties, changes in immunoreactivity and iodination characteristics,
acquisition of an increased capacity for glycolysis, modification of adenylate
cyclase activity, alterations in cellular phospholipid and phospholipid-like
fatty acid content and an increased ability to adhere to the zona pellucida
of the egg. Whether similar modifications occur in human spermatozoa during
epididymal migration is unknown. Biochemical changes observed in human
spermatozoa during epididymal transit involve the formation of disulfide
bonds within the sperm nucleus and tail and the oxidation of sperm membrane
sulfhydryl groups. These changes are thought to provide improved structural
integrity to the sperm membrane. The changes in structural integrity of
sperm may be necessary for the development of progressive motility and
successful penetration of eggs.Protein secretion and the storage capacity
of the epididymis has been shown to be profoundly affected by changes
in epididymal temperature in animals. Some have even postulated that the
driving force for evolution of the scrotal location of testes is to have
the epididymis maintained at a temperature below that of body core temperature,
in the scrotum. Whether the functions of the human epididymis are similarly
affected by body temperature is unknown. The potential influence of temperature
on epididymal function in man may be an important consideration in explaining
the relationship between varicocele and male infertility. If temperature
significantly affects human epididymal function, then it could explain
improvements in semen parameters that may occur less than three months
(one full cycle of spermatogenesis) after varicoceletomy.The human spermatozoon
is approximately 60 µm in length. Normal forms have an oval sperm
head, 4.5 µm long and 3 µm wide, consisting principally of
a nucleus, which contains the highly compacted chromatin material, and
the acrosome, a membrane-bound organelle that covers 40-70% of the surface
of the sperm head and contains the enzymes required for penetration of
the outer vestments of the egg prior to fertilization. The middle piece
of the spermatozoon is a highly organized segment consisting of helically
arranged mitochondria surrounding a set of outer dense fibers and the
characteristic 9 + 2 microtubular structure of the sperm axoneme. The
mitochondria contain the enzymes required for oxidative metabolism and
the production of adenosine triphosphate (ATP), the primary energy source
for the cell. Absence of some components of the microtubules is associated
with immotile cilia in the sinus and pulmonary tracts, with resultant
pulmonary and sinus infections. The association of sperm immotility with
upper respiratory infections (Young's syndrome) due to ciliary dysfunction
or absent dynein cross-arms between the microtubules (Kartagener's syndrome)
resulting in bronchiectasis and nonmotile sperm have been well documented.
Other syndromes of ciliary dysfunction have recently been described in
children with recurrent sinusitis (ciliary dyskinesia). It is yet to be
demonstrated whether the boys affected with the childhood manifestations
of ciliary dyskinesia will suffer from infertility problems after puberty.
The highly specialized structure and physiology of the spermatozoon is
marvelously suited for its single purpose: to carry genetic material to
the egg during reproduction.The rate of transport of fluid through the
vas deferens is not known in the human. Just prior to ejaculation, the
testes are brought up close to the abdomen and fluid is rapidly transported
through the vas deferens toward the region of the ejaculatory ducts and
subsequently into the prostatic urethra. After ejaculation, intravasal
fluid is transported back toward the epididymis and occasionally into
the seminal vesicles as well. The retrograde transport of sperm to the
seminal vesicles has been documented by videoradiography during ejaculation
after vasography. The return of sperm to the seminal vesicles after ejaculation
may help explain the prolonged presence of sperm in the ejaculate for
some men after vasectomy.The ejaculatory ducts enter the prostatic urethra
just lateral to the verumontanum. In the case of obstruction of the ejaculatory
ducts, resection of the floor of the prostate should be performed just
lateral to the midline and superior to the verumontanum. Vasography can
be performed prior to transurethral resection (TUR) of the ejaculatory
ducts with placement of methylene blue in the vasography fluid. This allows
the surgeon to cystoscopically identify the lack of flow of dye and confirm
relief of obstruction of the ejaculatory ducts during TUR.The ejaculate
consists of components from different accessory organs. Each of these
organs and the characteristics of the fluid that they produce is listed
below. These characteristics can be used clinically to evaluate ejaculatory
dysfunction.
Understanding
Male Infertility
By Marc Goldstein, M.D., FACS
Infertility effects one in every six couples who are trying to conceive.
In at least half of all cases of infertility a male factor is a major
or contributing cause. This means that about 10% of all men in the United
States who are attempting to conceive suffer from infertility.
Historically, infertility has been considered a women's disease. It is
only within the last fifty years that the importance of the male factor
contribution to infertility has been recognized. The mistaken notion that
infertility is associated with impotence or decreased masculinity may
contribute to this fear. The good news is that the rapid research advances
in the area of male reproduction have brought about dramatic changes in
the ability to both diagnose and treat male infertility. The majority
of couples suffering from infertility can now be helped to conceive a
child on their own.
The most common identifiable cause of infertility in men is varicocele.
This is a condition of enlarged veins in the scrotum that causes abnormalities
in the temperature regulation of the testis. Enzymes that are responsible
for both sperm and hormone (testosterone) production have an optimal temperature
at which they operate most effectively. If this temperature is elevated
by even one degree, sperm and testosterone production are adversely effected.
The evidence for the negative effect of varicocele on testicular function
in male fertility is now overwhelming. What is less certain, however,
is the effect of repairing the varicocele on restoring testicular function.
Dozens of reports have been published demonstrating the benefit of varicocele
surgery. However in most of these reports, controlled studies were lacking.
Microscopes were not used in older surgical procedures, which made it
extremely difficult to locate the tiny artery that provides the major
source of nourishment for the testis. Subsequently this artery was often
tied off which clearly was unlikely to improve testicular function. Tiny
lymph ducts were also inadvertently tied off, often causing a condition
called "hydrocele," which is a bag of fluid that develops around
the testicle.
These results led me and a colleague, Joel Marmar, to independently and
simultaneously develop a microsurgical technique of varicocelectomy employing
an operating microscope providing magnification between 6 and 30 power.
This enabled positive identification and preservation of the main artery
and the lymph ducts eliminating potential damage to the testicle as well
as eliminating the complication of hydrocele. Using these techniques in
several thousands of patients, the average healthy sperm count after repair
of the large varicoceles has been shown to increase 128%. In addition,
the first prospective randomized study comparing varicocelectomy to no
surgery was sponsored by the World Health Organization (WHO) and reported
in Fertility and Sterility. The results showed the pregnancy rate in couples
where men with varicoceles underwent surgery was three times higher than
when men did not undergo surgery.
The second major cause of infertility in men is blockages or obstructions
of the male reproductive tract. This is particularly true for men with
zero sperm count, a condition called "azoospermia." Men with
zero sperm count can be divided into two broad groups:
1.
men who have an obstruction problem or blockage, meaning they are making
sperm, but the sperm can't get out, or
2. men who have a production problem, meaning they are not making
sperm, a condition called "non-obstructive " azoospermia.
" We
can easily determine which group an infertile male is in by doing a testicular
biopsy, also using a microscope to minimize discomfort and complications.Blockage
can also be caused by a urinary tract infection or by the sexually transmitted
diseases chlamydia and gonorrhea. Bacteria can infect the tiny duct called
the "epididymis," which is essentially a swimming school for
sperm before they are able to swim to fertilize an egg. Infection of the
epididymis can cause scarring and blockage, inhibiting the sperm from
leaving the duct to fertilize an egg. With the use of microscopes employing
30-power magnification, blockage repair success rates are extremely high.One
of the most common causes of blockage is vasectomy. Approximately 500,000
to a million men undergo vasectomy each year in this country for permanent
birth control. With an increase in divorce rates coast-to-coast, the demand
for reversal of vasectomy is also growing. Currently, using a new technique
we developed here at The New York Presbyterian Hospital-Weill Medical
College of Cornell University called the microdot technique, we have achieved
return of sperm in 99% of men undergoing vasectomy reversal in whom we
find sperm in at least one of their vas ducts.Approximately 1% of all
infertile men are born with the congenital absence of the vas deferens,
the "equivalent" of a vasectomy. Unfortunately, there are no
artificial tubes strong enough to replace the vas deferens. However, we
are now able to help such men conceive using an operating microscope to
retrieve sperm from the tiny ducts of the epididymis, freeze them and
use them later for in- vitro fertilization (IVF) with the injection of
the single sperm directly into an egg.The most exciting new development
in the field of male infertility is the ability to treat men with severe
sperm production problems called non-obstructive azoospermia. Even though
these men may have no sperm in their semen, we can now find sperm between
the cells of the testicles in almost half of these cases. Using an operating
microscope, the medical team at The New York Presbyterian Hospital-Weill
Medical College of Cornell University, including Drs. Schlegel, Girardi,
Rosenwaks, Davis, Palermo and other colleagues, has been able to achieve
pregnancies in half of those men in whom sperm can be found within the
testicle. Genetic testing of these men with non-obstructive azoospermia
has revealed that 10% to 15% are missing a tiny piece of their Y chromosome.
This condition is called micro Y deletion. Human beings have 46 chromosomes,
males have one X chromosome and one Y chromosome and females have two
X chromosomes. The Y chromosome carries the genes that are responsible
for producing sperm. Men who have low to no sperm count might be missing
a small piece of that Y chromosome. Unfortunately helping men with micro
Y deletion have children almost guarantees their male children will have
the same infertility problem. However, these children will be healthy
in every other way.Artificial techniques of reproduction have advanced
to the point where a single sperm can be physically injected into an egg.
This procedure, called intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI), was developed
in Belgium by Gianpiero Palermo, a physician/scientist who now works with
us at The New York-Cornell Hospital. ICSI has dramatically changed the
treatment available for even the most severe male factor infertility.
Because of this technique, 90% of all infertile men, including half of
all men with non-obstructive azoospermia, have the potential to conceive
their own genetic child.Our ability to combat male infertility has never
been stronger. It is entirely possibly that, within 10 to 20 years, scientists
will be able to take cells from any tissue in a man's body and induce
these cells to fertilize an egg using some future version of ICSI. The
steps in such a process are very complex and not understood at present.
Once the process is mastered, however, male infertility will become a
thing of the past.
What's New in Male Infertility Treatment at Cornell
The Fertility Evaluation:
1. Introduction
2. Fertility History
3. Sexual History
4. Ejaculate History
5. Medical History
6. Physical Examination
7. Semen Analysis
8. Endocrine Evaluation
Introduction
Infertility is defined as a couple's inability to achieve pregnancy following
one year of appropriately timed and unprotected intercourse. By this criterion
it has been estimated that approximately 15-20% of couples attempting
to achieve pregnancy are unable to do so. A female factor is the primary
etiology in approximately 40% of these couples and another 30 - 40% are
pure male factor. A combination of male and female factors accounts for
the remaining 20% to 30% of cases. This suggests that in more than 50%
of couples presenting for infertility evaluation, a male factor is contributory.
Conservatively estimated, this means that 2.5 million American men would
potentially benefit from fertility evaluation. Historically, the approach
to the infertile couple has started with an evaluation of the female,
primarily because it is usually the female partner who has initiated a
workup by consultation with her gynecologist. It makes more sense, however,
to start with the male partner, whose initial evaluation may be performed
rapidly and noninvasively. Despite the availability of advanced reproductive
technologies, detection of the problem causing male infertility and institution
of directed treatment is possible in most cases. This specific treatment
of the "male problem" is often more successful, less expensive
and possibly less invasive than ICSI or other assisted reproductive treatments.
In addition, about 1% of men who present with the symptom of "infertility"
will actually have a serious medical problem causing the infertility that,
if left untreated, may jeopardize a man's health or life. The most important
part of the evaluation of the infertile male is the history and physical
examination. Even in this era of "high-tech" medicine it has
been our experience that in 90 % of cases an accurate impression is obtained
from an initial visit after a thorough history, physical examination,
and light microscopic examination of a semen specimen. Further testing
usually serves to confirm the diagnosis and help direct the course of
therapy.
Fertility History
Prior to arrival at the office, the patient is asked to fill out, at home
with the partner, a detailed fertility questionnaire The history begins
with an assessment of the couple's prior and current fertility status.
The age of the partners and the duration of unprotected intercourse is
established. Fertility evaluation is appropriate sooner rather than later
when the female partner is over age 35 or there has been a history of
infertility in a prior relationship or risk factors leading the couple
to suspect that a fertility problem exists (eg, cryptorchidism, testicular
neoplasm, chemotherapy).For idiopathic infertility the chance of ultimate
success is inversely related to the duration of infertility. Female age
is an important factor. Our in vitro fertilization (IVF) program's results
steadily and inexorably decline after age 34. It should be established
as to whether the infertility is primary or secondary for each partner
and, if secondary, the nature and outcome of prior pregnancies with the
same or any previous partner. Any previous infertility evaluation or treatment
for either partner should be noted as well.
Sexual History
In approximately 5% of couples presenting for infertility evaluation,
sexual dysfunction is causative. Is the semen ejaculated into the vagina?
Does the couple use lubricants, jellies, oils, or saliva, most of which
are known to be somewhat spermicidal? If lubrication is necessary, we
recommend Astroglode, Replens or Mineral oil. Given an approximate 48-hr
viability of sperm within the female reproductive tract, timing intercourse
is important. Too frequent intercourse or compulsive masturbation depletes
sperm reserves. The sexual history should also include an assessment of
libido, which crudely reflects serum testosterone levels.
Ejaculate
History
The man should be questioned regarding the nature and volume of a typical
ejaculate. A markedly diminished semen volume and clear.waterlike fluid
suggests. absence of the seminal vesicle component associated with either
ejaculatory duct obstruction or congenital absence of the vas deferens
(CAV). Normal orgasm with low or absent semen volume should lead one to
suspect retrograde ejaculation and warrant examination of a postejaculatory
urine specimen for the presence of sperm. Semen that fails to liquefy
suggests prostatic dysfunction. Proteolytic enzymes present in prostatic
secretions cause liquefaction of the protein coagulum derived from the
seminal vesicles.
Medical History
Cryptorchidism means a hidden testis. It present in about 0.8% of newborn
or 1 year old males, is an important risk factor for infertility. Fifty
percent of men with a history of unilateral cryptorchidism and 90% of
men with a history of bilateral cryptorchidism are subfertile. Hernia
repair in infancy or childhood is associated with a 3-17% risk of injury
to the inguinal or retroperitoneal vas deferens. Postpubescent mumps is
associated with a 30% risk of unilateral orchitis and a 10% risk of bilateral
orchitis, which may result in severe ipsilateral abnormalities in spermatogenesis.
The approximate age of onset of puberty is ascertained. Men will usually
remember pubertal landmarks only if they were very early or very late.
Precocious puberty suggests an adrenal abnormality such as congenital
adrenal hyperplasia. Very delayed or incomplete sexual maturation suggests
hypogonadotropic hypogonadism (Kallmann's syndrome when associated with
anosmia) or pantesticular failure, such as Kleinfelter's syndrome.Any
and all conditions or illnesses for which the patient has been or is currently
being treated, including all medications currently or previously taken,
are documented. Many prescription drugs interfere with spermatogenesis,
including cimetidine, sulfasalazine, nitrofurantoin, and anabolic steroids.
Drugs of abuse such as alcohol, marijuana, and cocaine are directly gonadotoxic.
A detailed occupational history is directed toward identifying exposure
to gonadotoxic agents such as heat, ionizing radiation, heavy metals,
and pesticides. A family history directed at fertility problems in parents
and siblings may be important. Intrauterine exposure to diethylstilbestrol
(DES) is also associated with male genitourinary tract anomalies and dysfunction.
Physical
Examination
Physical examination is performed in a warm room by an examiner with warm-gloved
hands, Contraction of the dartos muscle induced by a cold room or cold
examining hands makes examination of the scrotum and its contents difficult.
A proper fertility examination does not consist of a casual observation
of the scrotum and palpation of its contents. Have the patient completely
disrobe and stand with his arms outstretched. Observe the general body
habitus and hair distribution. Men who are incompletely masculinized have
disproportionately long extremities due to absent or deficient androgen
stimulation required for epiphyseal closure at the time of puberty. This
is seen in men with hypogonadotropic hypogonadism (Kallmann's syndrome
when associated with absent sense of smell or other midline defects) or
Kleinfelter's syndrome.After evaluation of body habitus, the thyroid is
palpated and the heart and lungs auscultated. Chronic bronchitis associated
with congenital epididymal dysplasia is seen in Young's syndrome. Situs
inversus with associated immotile sperm is seen in immotile cilia (Kartagener's)
syndrome. The breasts are observed and palpated for gynecomastia, which
can be associated with estrogen secreting testicular neoplasms, adrenal
tumors, and liver disease. Nipple discharge or tenderness may be seen
with prolactin-secreting pituitary adenomas. The abdomen is palpated and
percussed. A large varicocele that does not collapse in the supine position
warrants a search for an abdominal mass. An enlarged liver suggests hepatic
dysfunction, which may be associated with infertility due to altered sex
steroid metabolism. The penis and urethral meatus is examined for condylomata.
The urethra is milked for discharge. The location of the meatus is noted.
Severe hypospadias may result in inadequate delivery of semen into the
vagina.Scrotal examination is first performed with the patient supine.
This allows a varicocele, if present, to collapse; testis size and consistency
can then be properly assessed. Use an orchidometer to measure testicular
size. Normal testicular volume ranges from 15 to 30 cm . The testes should
be firm in consistency. A change in testicular consistency is indicative
of testicular pathology. Small soft testes indicate poor spermatogenesis.
Small hard testes suggest postorchitis or posttorsion atrophy or Kleinfelter's
syndrome. Focal irregularities in consistency raise the suspicion of malignancy.
Smooth firm nodules palpated on the surface of the testis usually represent
tunica albuginea cysts. Mobile small hard bodies,corpora amylacea, may
be palpated floating within the tunica vaginalis. Transillumination of
the scrotum in a darkened room differentiates solid from cystic masses.
In general, testes that are normal in size and-consistency usually have
normal sperm production, whereas small-volume, soft testes are associated
with impaired spermatogenesis. The normal epididymis, posterolateral to
the testes, is soft and barely palpable. Induration, modularity, or irregularities
are suggestive of epididymal pathology. A full, firm, easily outlined
epididymis that is nontendcr suggests epididymal obstruction. Epididymal
cysts or spcruiutoccies are firm, smooth, transilluminate, and almost
always located in the caput. The vas deferens should be palpated bilaterally.
The vas is the diameter and consistency of a venetian blind cord, and
is usually posteromedial and separate from the internal spermatic cord
structures. We have observed bilateral congenital absence of the vas deferens
(CAV) in 1.3% of of patients presenting for infertility evaluation. With
a relaxed scrotum, the diagnosis of CAV can almost always be made by palpation.
These men will have azoospermia associated with low seminal volumes and
nonclotting clear ejaculate. Serum follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH)
is usually normal, reflecting normal spermatogenesis. Testes biopsy and
scrotal exploration are not necessary prior to therapy. Because the vas
deferens derives from the ureteral bud, CAV is associated with. an 11%
incidence of renal agenesis and abnormalities. A renal sonogram should
be obtained in all men with CAV. Most men with CAV test positive for cystic
fibrosis gene mutations, although they do not have any pulmonary manifestations
of this disease.We test the patient and their wives for cystic fibrosis
(CFTR) gene mutations and refer the couples for genetic counseling.Men
with cystic fibrosis (CFTR mutations in association with digestive and/or
pulmonary problems) will often have bilateral congenital absence of the
vas deferens. CAV, whether associated with cystic fibrosis or not, may
be treated using sperm retrieval and in vitro fertilization to effect
pregnancies.Large varicoceles are readily seen through the relaxed scrotal
skin in a warm room with the patient standing. Small varicoceles may be
appreciated as a distinct impulse and palpable dilation of the internal
spermatic veins during the Valsalva maneuver. The best method to elicit
a strong and sustained Valsalva is to tell the patient to bear down as
if having a bowel movement. If a varicocele is detected, the patient should
be placed supine. A varicocele should completely collapse when the patient
is supine. A large varicocele, which does not collapse in the supine position,
leads to suspicion of a retroperitoneal mass and an abdominal sonogram
is indicated. In the hands of an experienced sonographer scrotal ultrasound
with color flow Doppler is useful in the evaluation of questionable varicoceles,
especially in obese men or men with a small tight scrotum. Our monographic
criteria for the diagnosis of a varicocele is the presence of any internal
spermatic veins greater than 3 mm in diameter associated with retrograde
flow on Valsalva. Subclinical or questionable varicoceles are of limited
clinical interest. Our data has clearly shown that response to varicoceletomy
is related to varicocele size. Men with large varicoceles sustain a greater
improvement in semen quality following varicocele surgery than men with
small or subclinical varicoceles. Digital rectal examination is always
performed. The size and consistency of the prostate is noted. Masses,
cysts, irregularities, tenderness, and whether or not the seminal vesicles
are palpable are noted. Stool should be tested for occult blood.
Semen
Analysis
Semen specimens are obtained by masturbation into a sterile wide-mouth
container after 2-5 days of abstinence and analyzed within 2 hr of collection
. Two to three analyses, separated by at least a month, are required for
a meaningful evaluation. In the setting of a recent febrile illness or
exposure to gonadotoxic agents we would repeat the semen analysis no sooner
than 3 months later. Semen is initially an opalescent coagulum that liquefies
within 20-25 min of ejaculation. The coagulation protein derives from
the seminal vesicle. Liquefaction is secondary to the action of prostatic
proteases. Failure of liquefaction is due to abnormalities of the prostate
or its ducts. Normal ejaculate volume is between 2 and 6 mL. Sixty-five
percent of the volume is from the seminal vesicles, 30-35% from the prostate,
and 3-5% from the vasa. Seminal fructose derives from the seminal vesicles.
Azoospermia coupled with low ejaculate volume of nonclotting watery fluids
fructose-negative, Usually implies an obstruction of the ejaculatory duct.
If the vasa are Palpable a transrectal Ultrasound can be diagnostic. Patients
who are not azoospermic but oligo- or asthenospermic with a low semen
volume may have partial ejaculatory duct obstruction or retrograde specimen
is obtained by first having ejaculation. A postejaculatory urine specimen
is obtained by first having the patient empty his bladder prior to ejaculation
and then voiding following ejaculation into a separate container. Retrograde
ejaculation is commonly seen in diabetics as well as in men who have had
transurethral surgery at or near the bladder neck.Manual light microscopic
evaluation of sperm concentration, motility, and morphology is still the
gold standard. Computer-assisted semen analysis (CASA) is most useful
as a research tool and yet has not provided information that alters therapy.
Azoospermic specimens are frequently misread by the computer as oligospermic
and computerized morphology has not been perfected. CASA provides interesting
information on sperm velocity and angularity that is useful in a research
setting. Because pregnancy can be achieved with only one sperm, specimens
originally read as azoospermic should be centrifuged and the pellet examined
for sperm. Specimens with head-to-head or tail-to-tail agglutination are
evaluated for antisperm antibodies or infection. Infection may be inferred
from the presence of leukospermia (>1x 106 WBC/mL). Men with agglutination
or leukospermia should have their semen cultured for aerobic and anaerobic
organisms as well as Chlamydia and Mycoplasma. The penis and scroturn
should be washed with an antibacterial scrub Prior to culture to avoid
inadvertent contamination with skin or fecal flora.Proper interpretation
of morphologic parameters requires an understanding of the scoring system
and criteria employed by testing laboratory, Broadly viewed, profound
abnormalities in morphology are associated with poor fertilizing capacity
when strict criteria (Kruger) are used. Men with fewer than 40% perfectly
shaped sperm usually failed to fertilize without micromanipulation. Large
numbers of tapered sperm are seen in testes with elevated temperatures,
such as varicocele, cryptorchid, or retractile testes, or in the testes
of men who take saunas or hot baths. Antisperrn antibodies bound to sperm
are associated with lower pregnancy rates. Risk factors for antibodies
include torsion, epididymitis, orchitis, unilateral or partial obstruction,
and large varicoceles. These are all conditions associated with impairment
of the blood-testis barrier that usually prevents sperm antigens (which
appear at puberty) from being exposed to the general circulation. An immunobead
assay detects antibodies on the sperm and in the serum. High levels of
antibodies are most often seen with obstruction, in particular before
(in serum) and after (in serum and on sperm) vasectomy reversal. Low levels
of antibodies on sperm and moderate levels in serum are usually seen in
men with large varicoceles. A postcoital test is useful for evaluating
sperm-cervical mucus interaction. A fair to good semen analysis associated
with a poor postcoital test is an indication for intrauterine insemination
(IUI). Although IUI can overcome cervical mucus antibodies or decreased
counts, the success of IUI is dependent on the sperm's ability to fertilize
an egg, Therefore prior to instituting IUI, we obtain a sperm penetration
assay (SPA) that assesses the sperm's ability to bind and penetrate hamster
oocytes, which have been rendered zona pellucida-free. Tests are interpreted
as percent oocytes penetrated or sperm penetrations per oocyte. These
tests are not perfect but do correlate about 80% with the ability to penetrate
human eggs in vitro.
Semen Analysis Normal Ranges (WHO Criteria, 1992)
| Semen Characteristics |
Units |
WHO (1992 |
| Volume |
ml |
2.0 or more |
| pH |
pH units |
(7.2 - 8.0) |
| Sperm concentration |
x 106/ml |
20 or more |
| Total sperm count |
x 106/ejaculate |
> 40 or more |
| Motility (within 60 minutes of ejaculation) |
% Motile |
> 50 or more |
| Progression at 37oC |
Scale 0-4 |
3 - 4 |
| Morphology |
% Normal sperm |
>=30 |
| Vitality |
% Live sperm |
>=75 |
| White blood cells |
x 106/ml |
<1.0 |
Endocrine
Evaluation
Basic endocrine evaluation includes measurement of serum testosterone
(T) and follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH). Testosterone is necessary
for the development and maintenance of secondary sexual characteristics
and libido as well as initiation and maintenance of sperrnatogenesis.
Serum FSH crudely reflects the status of the serniniferous epithelium.
Elevated serum FSH results from impaired secretion of inhibin, a Sertoli
cell product that normal feeds back at the pituity and hypothalamus
to turn off FSH secretion and suggests abnormalities in the seminiferous
epithelium and subsequently spermatogenesis. An FSH level greater than
two to three times the upper limits of normal suggests severely impaired
seminiferous tubule , but may still be treatable. Luteinizing hormone
(LH) is stimulatory to the Leydig cells and hence T production. Isolated
LH abnormalities are very rare. LH levels need be obtained only in men
with abnormal T levels.Low levels of FSH, LH, and T are diagnostic of
hypogonadotropic hypogonadism. These men have a delay or failure in
the onset of puberty and therefore poorly developed secondary sexual
characteristics and small firm testes. Testosterone replacement will
masculinize these men but testicular growth and the initiation of spermatogenesis
requires gonadotropin replacement. Hypogonadotropic hypogonadism is
usually due to a pituitary tumor, with the most common pituitary lesion
being a benign prolactinoma. These are usually associated with a decreased
libido, an elevated serum prolactin level, and decreased serum T and
LH levels. Both macro and microadenomas are often best treated with
bromocriptine. Serum estrogens, prolactin, and adrenal steroids are
only measured if clinically indicated (low serum T, decreased libido,
gynecomastia, or a history of precocious puberty).
Testis
Biopsy
1.
Introduction
2. Technique of Open Testis Biopsy
3. Technique of Percutaneous Testis Biopsy
4. Technique of Percutaneous Testicular Needle Asperation
5. Interpretation
6. Complications
Introduction
Testis biopsy was first reported by Hotchkiss and Engle at The New York
Hospital-Cornell Medical Center in the late 1930s. The primary purpose
of testis biopsy is to distinguish between obstructive azoospermia and
primary seminiferous tubular failure. It is indicated in men who are
azoospermic with testis of normal size (greater than 15cc in volume),
normal consistency, palpable vasa deferentia and normal serum FSH levels.
Azoospermia in men with small soft testes and FSH levels elevated more
than twice normal is always due to primary germ cell failure and biopsy
may be helpful to rule out intratubular germ cell neoplasm (carcinoma-in-situ).
However, biopsy of men with presumed non-obstructed azoospermia should
only be performed if cryopreservation of the tissue is possible at the
same time. Men with borderline FSH levels and slightly soft small testes
probably have testicular failure and biopsy should only be performed
in these men when absolute confirmation of the diagnosis is required.
We no longer perform biopsy on men without palpable vasa. We have biopsied
a dozen such men and all of these biopsies have revealed virtually normal
spermatogenesis. The presence or absence of spermatozoa is the ultimate
and only determinant of whether the patient is a candidate for ICSI
(Intracytoplasmic Sperm Injection) using sperm retrieval. Also, testis
biopsy should almost always be performed bilaterally. Small firm testes
often have surprising good spermatogenesis. Biopsies of even large healthy
testis sometimes reveal maturation arrest.
Technique
of Open Testis Biopsy
Once the decision has been made to perform testis biopsy, it is the
obligation of the surgeon to provide a tissue sample adequate for good
pathological evaluation using a technique that minimizes trauma to the
specimen and prevents injury to the epididymis and testicular blood
supply. It also need to coordinate the time schedule with the IVF embrology
lab if performing of TESA at the same time. With the assistant stretching
the scrotal skin tightly,over the anterior surface of the testis and
assuring that the epididymis is posterior, bilateral 5 mm transverse
scrotal incisions provide good exposure with a minimum of scrotal skin
bleeding. The incision is carried through the skin and dartos muscle
and the tunica vaginalis is opened. Bleeders on the edges of the tunica
vaginalis are cauterized. The tunica albuginia is exposed and transfixed
with a 4-0 catgut suture armed with a small tapered needle (cutting
needles often cause more bleeding than the suture prevents). All bleeders
are coagulated prior to incising the tunics to prevent saturation of
the biopsy with blood. A 3 to 4 mm incision is made with the point of
the scalpel into the tunic and a pea-sized sample of seminiferous tubules
excised with a razor sharp iris scissors and deposited directly into
either Bouins, Zenkers, or collidine buffered glutaraldehyde solution.
Formalin fixation results in severe distortion of the testicular histology,
making these specimens almost impossible to read. It should never be
used for testis biopsy. A second specimen is placed on a slide, a drop
of saline or Ringer's is added, and the specimen is squashed under a
coverslip to allow sperm to leave the tubules. The squash prep is examined
under a microscope using phase contrast. The presence of sperm with
tails, especially motile, on the squash prep is almost 100% predictive
of obstruction. The tunics are closed with a running 5-0 polypropylene
monofflainent suture. Skin sutures are not required. The wounds need
only be covered with Bacitracin ointment and a fluff type dressing held
in place with snug scrotal supporter. Antibiotics are unnecessary. Tylenol
or Tylenol with codeine provides adequate analgesia.
Technique
of Percutaneous Testis Biopsy
Percutaneous testis biopsy using a Tru-Cut type of devise has been performed
as an office procedure under local anesthesia. It has been used fo evaluation
of both histology and cytology. This blind biopsy procedure could result
in unintentional injury to either the epididymis or testicular artery
coursing under the surface of the tunica albuginia. In additiona, we
have often found that sepcimens obtained in this way often contain only
three to six tubules with poorly preserved architecture. Specimens obtained
in this way can be used to extract sperm for ICSI in case of obstruction.
Technique
of Percutaneous Testicular Fine Needle Aspiration (TFNA)
Aspiration with a fine gauge needle may be less risky and painful than
percutaneous biopsy. Evaluation of such material with flow eytometry
offers promise as a useful diagnostic tool. Only a few studies of such
techniques have been reported. Until standards for the evaluation of
aspirated material are well established, open testis biopsy is the diagnostic
procedure of choice. Fresh unfixed testis biopsy materials should be
examined in the operating room to determine sperm are presented and
whether they are motile. Sperm can be obtained this way for ICSI in
case of obstruction.
Interpretation
Examination of properly fixed biopsy material by light microscopy provides
most of the information necessary to make an accurate diagnosis. Mature
spermatids and sperms are easy to differentiate from other germ cell
elements. An average of at least twenty mature spermatids and/or sperms
per/tubule from at least 10 counted tubules predicts a total sperm count
of at least 10 million. Azoospermic or severely oligospermic men with
spermatid counts considerably higher than this are almost certain to
be obstructed. Electron microscopic examination of testicular biopsy
material yields little additional information on the cause of most testicular
disorders. The electron microscope is useful in the diagnosis of rare
disorders such as Kartageners Syndrome, in which the dynein side arms
are absent from sperm tails. Such diagnoses can be more easily made
by a thorough history and physical examination. Abnormalities of sperm
head shape, such as round heads or absent acrosomes are clearly defined
with the electron microscope, but can also be diagnosed with routine
staining and light microscopy. Flow cytometric evaluation of testis
biopsies can detect different patterns of nucleic acid content and distribution.
Maturation beyond the meiotic stage can readily be detected with flow
cytometry. This technique might prove to be a useful screening tools
when standards have been validated.
Complications
When performed with care, testis biopsy is associated with few complications.
The most serious misadventure associated with testis biopsy would be
biopsy of the wrong structure, in particular biopsy of the epididymis.
If examination of the biopsy material reveals epididymis with sperm
within the epididymal tubule, obstruction of the epididymis at the site
of the biopsy is certain. If, however, biopsy of the epididymis reveals
the absence of sperm in the tubules, no serious harm has been done,
and the patient is either obstructed above the level of the biopsy or
has primary seminiferous tubular failure and is not making sperm. Large
hematomas can result from testis biopsy if the testicular artery on
the surface of the tunica albuginia has been injured. If this injury
is not recognized, hematomas can grow to frightening size and require
drainage. Leaving the tunica vaginalis and tiny skin wounds open will
almost always prevent hematoma formation, at the very worst, the patient
would have bloody bandages and the bleeding would eventually subside.
Because of the rich testicular blood supply, wound infection is extremely
rare in the absence of hematoma. Antibiotics are not routinely indicated
after testis biopsy.Testicular atrophy might result if the testicular
artery is injured during the course of a blind percutaneous biopsy or
a biopsy under local anesthesia using a blind cord block.Placement of
the biopsy material in the incorrect fixative such as formalin, or inadequate
sampling of the testicular tissue, renders the biopsy use less and it
would then have to be repeated
Vasography
Vasography is indicated in men with at least one palpable vas deferens
azoospermia, and a testis biopsy indicating normal spermatogenesis,
or in men with low-volume ejaculates with poorly motile sperm in whom
ejaculatory duct obstruction is possible. Vasography should be performed
only at the time of planned reconstruction. It should not be undertaken
at the time of biopsy unless immediate reconstruction is planned, dictated
by the presence of mature spermatids with tails and preferably motile
on immediate cytological evaluation. When the cause or site of the obstruction
is unknown, the vas is approached through a vertical 3 - 4-cm incision
in the upper scrotum, the testis is delivered, and the vas is separated
from adjacent spermatic cord structures at the junction of the straight
and convoluted portions. Care is taken to isolate the vas cleanly, preserving
the vasal vessels. The isolated vas is stabilized using a straight clainp
as a platform and hemitransected with a microknife under 15 power magnification.
Any fluid exuding from the lumen is placed on a slide, mixed with a
drop of saline, covered with a coversjip, and examined microscopically.
If no sperm are found in the vasal fluid then an epididymal obstruction
is likely. If sperm are present in the vasal fluid then a vasal or ejaculatory
duct obstruction is likely, Copious thick white fluid, devoid of sperm
in a dilated vas, indicates a vasal and epididymal obstruction. If no
fluid is present and none can be expressed by gentle pressure on the
testis and epididymis, then gentle barbitage of the testicular end is
performed with 0.1-0.2 mL of saline or Ringer's solution. If an epididymal
obstruction is suspected, this does not rule out the possibility of
a secondary abdominal side obstruction and does not preclude the need
for vasography. A 25-gauge angiocath is gently advanced into the abdominal
side of the hemitransected vas. Gentle, low-pressure instillation of
saline or Ringer's lactate will determine abdominal side patency. Easy
flow confirms patency and requires no further vasal study. Resistance
to flow indicates obstruction, the level of which must be determined.
In this setting, the abdominal vas is usually dilated and a 3-Fr whistle
tip ureteral catheter passed toward the seminal vesicles. The calibrations
will determine the distance of the obstruction from the level of heniitransection.
These catheters may also be employed to instill a 50% concentration
of water-soluble contrast media for formal vasography. If the obstruction
is determined to be at the ejaculatory ducts (Fig. 3), the ureteral
catheters may be employed for the injection of,methylene blue contrast
to aid in subsequent transurethral resection of the ejaculatory ducts.
Vasography sites are carefully closed employing microsurgical technique
with interrupted 10-0 nylon for mucosa and interrupted 9-0 nylon for
the muscularis and adventitia
Varicocele
Introduction
Etiology
Pathophysiology
Diagnosis
Surgical Treatment
1. Indications
2. Microsurgical technique
Complications
of varicocele Repair
Results
Cost-effectiveness
Summary
Reference and Suggested Reading
Introduction
Varicoceles
are abnormally dilated testicular veins (pampiniform plexus) of in the
scrotum, which is normally secondary to internal spermatic vein reflux.
Varicocele is found in approximately 15% of the general population, 35%
of men with primary infertility and in 75-81% of men with secondary infertility.
It is more common on the left side. In adolescents, the incidence of varicocele
is approximately 15%; the abnormality is extremely rare in prepubertal
boys
Although
most men with varicoceles are able to father children, there is abundant
evidence that varicoceles are detrimental to male fertility. A study by
the World Health Organization (WHO) on over 9,000 men showed that varicoceles
are commonly accompanied by decreased testicular volume, impaired sperm
quality, and a decline in Leydig cell function.2 Another report by Johnson
and colleagues showed that 70% of healthy, asymptomatic military recruits
with palpable varicoceles had an abnormality on semen analysis.3 Furthermore,
studies in animals4,5 and humans6-8 suggest that varicoceles cause progressive
testicular damage over time. It appears that surgical repair of varicoceles
not only halts this declines in testicular function but often reverses
it. Whether the improvements in semen parameters, seen in 80% of men after
varicocele ligation, translate into improved pregnancy and delivery rates
has been a matter of ongoing controversy. Recent studies employing non-operated
control groups clearly indicate that varicocelectomy does improve pregnancy
rates.48
Etiology
Presumably due to anatomic differences, varicoceles are much more common
on the left side. The incidence of bilaterality is anywhere from 15 to
50% but isolated right varicoceles are fairly rare. The left internal
spermatic vein empties into the left renal vein. It is 8 to 10cm longer
than the right internal spermatic vein, which drains into the inferior
vena cava. This is believed to result in increased hydrostatic pressure
that is transmitted down the vein to the scrotal pampiniform plexus, causing
dilation and tortuosity of these vessels.9 Elevated pressure in the left
internal spermatic vein may also result from compression of the left renal
vein between the aorta and the superior mesenteric artery, a phenomenon
known as the "nutcracker effect." Radiologic studies have documented
relative distention of the proximal left renal vein suggesting partial
distal obstruction.10
Varicoceles
may also arise secondary to reflux of venous blood into the pampiniform
plexus as a result of absent or incompetent valves within the internal
spermatic vein. A report by Braedel et al. on over 650 consecutive men
with varicoceles revealed that 73% had absent internal spermatic venous
valves on venography.11
Varicoceles
generally become clinically manifest at the time of puberty. Although
there is no data to suggest a genetic basis for these lesions and hereditary
patterns have not been identified, these issues have been poorly studied.
Retroperitoneal masses such as sarcomas, lymphomas, and renal tumors have
been known to cause varicoceles by obstructing venous outflow from the
testicles but varicoceles are not known to be a component of any clinically
recognized syndrome.
Pathophysiology
Despite a
large number of animal and human studies, the exact mechanism whereby
varicoceles cause impaired testicular function remains poorly understood.
Theories include abnormally high scrotal temperature, hypoxia due to venous
stasis, dilution of intratesticular substrates (e.g. testosterone), imbalances
of the hypotalamic-pituitary-gonadal axis, and reflux of renal and adrenal
metabolites down the spermatic vein. Data exist to both support and refute
each of these possibilities. In addition, nitric oxide,12 reactive oxygen
species,13 and regulators of apoptosis14 have all recently been implicated
in the pathophysiology of varicoceles. It appears that cigarette smoking
in the presence of varicocele has a greater adverse effect than either
factor alone.15
The
most vigorously studied pathophysiologic theory is that of increased testicular
temperature. It has long been observed that even minor fluctuation in
temperature can affect spermatogenesis and sperm function.16,17 It has
been suggested that varicoceles impair testicular thermoregulation by
disrupting the countercurrent heat exchange mechanism in the pampiniform
venous plexus. Reversal of testicular blood flow abnormalities and a drop
in testicular temperature have been seen in the rat after varicocele repair.18
Recently, Wright and colleagues showed in humans that scrotal skin surface
temperatures were elevated in men with varicoceles compared to control
patients. Following varicocele ligation, scrotal temperatures returned
to a level nearly identical to those of controls.19 Previous studies have
demonstrated that scrotal skin surface temperatures reliably reflect intratesticular
temperatures.20 The pathophysiology of varicocele is probably multi-factorial.
Diagnosis
Varicoceles
are defined as dilations of veins of the pampiniform plexus, which are
believed to be caused by incompetent valves of the internal spermatic
veins.
The diagnosis
of a clinical significant varicocele is generally made on physical examination
of the scrotum and its contents. The patient is examined in the supine
and standing position in a warm room that promotes relaxation of the scrotal
dartos muscle and facilitates accurate evaluation for varicocele. The
scrotum should be inspected carefully for any easily visible dilated veins
(Figure 1a, 1b). The spermatic cord should be palpated between thumb and
forefingers for palpable vein. Both sides of spermatic cords should be
palpated while the patient performs a Valsalva maneuver.
The severity
of the varicoceles is graded I through III using the system outlined in
following table 1. Grade I varicoceles can be thought of as small, Grade
II, medium and Grade III, large. Varicoceles should significantly diminish
in size when the patient assumes the supine position. If the varicocele
remains prominent with the patient supine, this finding suggests a mechanical
obstruction to testicular venous outflow such as a retroperitoneal mass
(sarcoma, lymphoma or a renal tumor with venous thrombus). An abdominal
ultrasound or CT scan should be obtained to evaluate the retroperitoneum
in these patients.
Table1: Clinical
Varicocele Classification
| Classification |
Definition |
| Clinical ( palpable): |
|
Grade III ( Large)
|
- Easily visible ( Figure1A)
|
Grade II (Medium)
|
- Palpable at rest (without Valsalva maneuver), invisible.
|
Grade I ( Small)
|
- Palpable with Valsalva maneuver only
|
Subclinical ( not palpable)
|
- Vein larger than 3 mm on ultrasound; Doppler reflux on Valsalva
maneuver
|
Scrotal ultrasonography with color flow Doppler imaging may prove useful
in equivocal cases or in patients with a body habitus that makes accurate
physical examination of the scrotum impossible. Using ultrasonography,
the diameter of the internal spermatic vein can be measured and retrograde
flow through the vein during Valsalva documented. Veins that are greater
the 3.5mm can generally be detected on physical exam. Those that are 2.7mm
or less are usually not palpable and have been termed "subclinical"
varicoceles.21 The need for diagnosing and treating subclinical varicoceles
is controversial.22 Recent studies have indicated that repair of subclinical
varicoceles is of questionable value.23 However, other reports have indicated
that repair of small palpable or subclinical right varicoceles may be
beneficial if present in conjunction with a larger left sided varix.24-26
Venography
is generally considered the most accurate method of varicocele diagnosis
when performed by an experienced interventional radiologist.27 Due to
its invasiveness, venography is usually only performed in the research
setting to document recurrences or for a comparison to other, less invasive
diagnostic techniques.
A multi-center
WHO study on the influence of varicocele on fertility parameters demonstrated
that the mean Testosterone (T) concentration of men older than 30 years
of age with varicoceles was significantly lower than that of younger patients
with varicoceles, whereas this trend was not seen in men without varicoceles.2,32
When exogenous hCG is administered to men with varicoceles, a blunted
T response is observed compared to controls without varicoceles.28 Repairing
varicoceles appears to improve serum Testosterone (T) levels. This observation
was made over twenty years ago by Comhaire and Vermeulen29 and was confirmed
recently in a larger series by Su, et al.30 Taken together, these findings
indicate that varicoceles result in abnormal Leydig cell function in some
men, but these patients may also be the ones to most benefit from surgical
repair.
The abnormalities
of semen parameters in infertile men with varicocele were first objectively
described by Macleod in 1965 57. In that study, Macleod observed that
the vast majority of semen samples, obtained from 200 infertile men with
varicocele, were found to have an increased number of abnormal forms,
decreased motility and lower mean sperm counts. This 'stress pattern',
which is also characterized by an increased number of tapered forms and
immature cells, was also reported in other studies. However, other investigators
have shown that the characteristic stress pattern is not a sensitive marker
for varicocele, and believe that it is not diagnostic of this pathology.
A large number of studies have evaluated the effects of varicocelectomy
on semen parameters. Most of these studies have demonstrated an improvement
in sperm density with or without a concomitant increase in sperm motility
and morphology after varicocelectomy, suggesting a cause and effect relationship
between varicocele and abnormal semen parameters. However, because the
bulk of the reported outcome data on varicocelectomy comes from uncontrolled
or poorly designed controlled studies, the value of those results is limited.
The impact of the grade of varicocele on the magnitude of improvement
in semen quality after varicocelectomy is equivocal. Steckel et al., reported
that men with larger varicoceles present with lower sperm densities, and
show greater relative improvement in semen quality than men with smaller
varicoceles who present with higher mean sperm densities59. On the other
hand, Braedel et al., demonstrated less of an improvement in sperm density
in men with grade 3 varicocele, than men with smaller varicoceles.60
Although
the relationship between varicocele size and seminal improvement following
varicocele repair was controversial for many years, the overall rates
of seminal improvement following varicocele repair have been approximately
65%. Moreover, some recent studies indicated that the degree of improvement
of semen parameters following varicocele repair is directly proportional
to the size of the varicocele repaired surgically.
Surgical
Treatment
1. Indications: The majority of men with varicoceles remain fertile and
asymptomatic. Therefore, treatment of all varicoceles is clearly unnecessary.
The authors advocate surgical correction of clinically detectable varicoceles
associated with abnormal semen parameters in an infertile couple following
appropriate evaluation of the female partner. This includes men with azoospermia
and very severe oligospermia.
Palpable
varicoceles should be corrected in adolescent boys when accompanied by
ipsilateral testicular atrophy or if the varicocele is very large. It
has been suggested that adolescents with varicocele and an abnormal gonadotropin
response to LHRH may also benefit from repair.32 Finally, varicoceles
associated with debilitating testicular pain may be considered for repair.
A variety
of surgical approaches have been advocated for varicocele repair (varicocelectomy),
including open surgical, laparoscopic, and percutaneous techniques. Ideally,
the perfect procedure would be one that ligates both the veins contributing
to the varix at the time of repair and those that could cause a recurrence
in the future. However, some veins clearly must be preserved so as to
allow drainage of blood from the testis and prevent vascular engorgement.
Therefore, the ideal procedure should be one that leaves the testicular
arteries, lymphatics, and vas deferens intact. A minimally invasive procedure
which reduces morbidity, pain and recovery time is also desirable.
2. Microsurgical
Technique: We believe that the technique most closely approaching this
"ideal" is the mini-incision, inguinal, or subinguinal microsurgical
varicocelectomy with delivery of the testicle.33 Although it is a technically
demanding approach, the real advantages of the microsurgical approach
to varicocele repairs are reliable identification and preservation of
the testicular artery or arteries, cremasteric artery or arteries, and
lymphatic channels and reliable identification of all internal spermatic
veins and gubernacular veins. Delivery of the testis assures direct visual
access to all possible routes of venous return, including external spermatic,
cremasteric, and gubernacular veins. Postoperatively, venous return is
via the vasal veins, which drain into the internal pudental system and
usually have competent valves.
The introduction
of microsurgical technique to varicocelectomy has resulted in a substantial
reduction in the incidence of postoperative hydrocele formation and testicular
atrophy or azoospermia, respectively. This is because the lymphatics can
be more easily identified and preserved. Furthermore, the use of magnification
enhances the ability to identify and preserves the 0.5 - 1.5-mm testicular
artery, thus avoiding the complications of atrophy or azoospermia.

Microsurgical
Approaches: After standard preparation and draping of the patient, the
position of the external inguinal ring is marked as " X" on
the skin. The incision extends about 2 cm from the mark following natural
skin line (Figure 2). The size of the incision depends somewhat on the
obesity of the patient and the size of the testicle being delivered.

The spermatic
cord is exposed by hooking an index finger under the external inguinal
ring while sliding a small Richardson retractor in the incision along
the dorsum of the index finger and pulling in the opposite direction .The
cord is encircled with a Babcock clamp (Figure 3). With gentle traction
the cord is exposed, encircled with a Babcock clamp, and delivered. The
ilioinguinal and genital branches of the genitofemoral nerve are excluded
and preserved. The Babcock clamp is replaced with a Penrose drain and
the testis is delivered.
The gubernaculum
is carefully inspected and any veins encountered are either electrocoagulated
or clipped and divided depending on their size. All perforating external
spermatic veins and gubemacular veins are also divided (Figure 4). The
gubernacular veins have been demonstrated radiographically to account
for 10% of varicocele recurrences10.

Delivery
of the testicle enables the surgeon to identify and ligate these vessels,
which are responsible for some varicocele recurrences (Figure 5).

Once
all external spermatic perforators and gubernacular veins have been divided,
the testicle is returned to the scrotum and the spermatic cord remains
elevated over a large Penrose drain for stabilization in preparation for
microscopic examination (Figure 6)


The
operating microscope is then brought into the operating field and the
cord is examined under 8 to 15-power magnification. The internal and external
spermatic fascias are opened longitudinally and the cord is examined.
The magnification is increased to 15 power and 1 % papverine is dripped
over the cord. The testicular artery is identified by its pulsation and
is dissected free from all surrounding tissue, tiny veins, and lymphatics
using a fine-tipped, non-locking micro-needle holder and Pierse tissue
forceps. The pulsation of suspected by seeing a pulsating column of blood
appears just over the needle holder. The artery is identified and then
encircled with a zero silk suture to preserve it (Figure 7). Any additional
artery encountered are also identified and preserved in this manner. All
remaining internal spermatic veins with the exception of the vasal veins
are clipped with hemoclips or ligated and divided. Care is taken to preserve
a majority of lymphatics as these can contribute to hydrocele formation
postoperatively when divided.
At the completion
of varicocelectomy, the cord should contain only the testicular artery
or arteries, vas deferens and associated vessels, cremasteric muscle (with
its veins ligated and artery preserved), and spermatic cord lymphatics.
This meticulous
approach to varicocelectomy requires extensive training and the use of
a high-quality operating microscope. Even loupe magnification is inadequate
for the reliable identification of the tiny vascular channels and lymphatics
of the spermatic cord. An experienced surgeon can perform this procedure
in less than 30 minutes per side, and the procedure is always performed
on an ambulatory basis.
Using the
microsurgical technique at Cornell, we have reviewed our results of over
1,500 men who underwent microsurgical varicocelectomy, the couples' pregnancy
rate was 43 % after one year and 69% after 2 years compared to 16% in
couples with men who declined surgery and had hormone treatment or used
insemination. There have been only 14 recurrences (1%), no hydrocele,
no testicular atrophy, and a 1% incidence of inadvertent unilateral (one
side only) testicular artery ligation14.
Some authors
have suggested that the technique employed should be governed by the clinical
situation. In a recent report, Abdulmaaboud et al. advocated percutaneous
embolization for isolated left-sided varicoceles and laparoscopy for bilateral
varicoceles.35 Failure rate for Balloon occlusion is 25% and laparoscopic
approach requires general anesthesia and is also with great potential
morbidity.
Complications
of Varicocele Repair
Hydrocele formation is the most common complication reported after non-microsurgical
varicocelectomy, with an average incidence of about 7%36 Hydroceles form
secondary to ligation of the testicular lymphatics. At least half of all
post-
varicocelectomy
hydroceles grow to a size that produces sufficient discomfort to warrant
surgical hydrocelectomy. The effect of hydrocele function on spermatogenesis
and fertility is unknown. Theoretically, large hydroceles may impair testicular
function by insulating the testis and preventing normal thermoregulation.
Use of the operating microscope has essentially eliminated the development
of hydroceles following varicocelectomy.37, 38
Testicular
artery ligation is also a common complication of non-microsurgical varicocelectomy
although its true incidence is unknown.39 Injury or ligation of the testicular
artery may cause testicular atrophy, impaired spermatogenesis, or both.
Animal studies indicate that testicular atrophy occurs anywhere from 20%
to 100% of the time following testicular artery ligation.40,41 In humans,
Penn, et al. reported a 14% incidence of frank testicular atrophy, when
the testicular artery was purposefully ligated during renal transplantation.42
Optical magnification and/or the use of a fine tipped Doppler probe facilitate
identification and preservation of the testicular artery.
The incidence
of varicocele recurrence following surgical repair varies from 1% to 45%.
The incidence of recurrence depends upon the type of procedure performed
and the use of magnification. Venographic studies have shown that recurrent
varicoceles are caused by periarterial, parallel inguinal, midretroperitoneal,
gubernacular and transcrotal collateral veins.36 The only approach equipped
to deal with these vessels is the inguinal or subinguinal microscopic
technique with delivery of the testis. A comparison of the various approaches
to varicocelectomy is summarized in table 2.
Table
2: Techniques of Varicocelectomy
| Technique |
Artery Preserved |
Hydrocele (%) |
Recurrence (%) |
Potential for Serious Morbidity |
| Microscopic inguinal |
Yes |
0 |
1 |
no |
| Retroperitoneal |
No |
7 |
15-25 |
no |
| Conventional inguinal |
No |
3-30 |
5-15 |
no |
| Laparoscopic |
Yes |
12 |
5-15 |
yes |
| Balloon |
Yes |
0 |
7-25 |
yes |
Our recurrence
rate at Cornell is less than 1%. Unintentional testicular artery ligation
occurs in less than 1% of cases and hydroceles have been essentially eliminated.
We have seen clinically significant improvements in semen parameters for
over 80% of patients and natural pregnancy rates of 43% and 69% at one
and two years respectively, controlling for female factors.
Results
Increasing evidence suggests that varicocele ligation improves semen quality
and pregnancy rates. Unfortunately, the bulk of this data comes from retrospective,
poorly controlled studies. Only two randomized, prospective, controlled
studies have been performed. Nieschlag and colleagues reported on 125
couples with varicoceles who underwent either angiographic embolization,
surgical ligation, or counseling.43 They found that semen parameters improved
significantly in the treatment groups but pregnancy rates were no different
than those couples receiving only counseling. Most of the varicoceles
in this study were small (Grade I) and a microsurgical, artery sparing
technique was not applied. A second study by Madgar, et al. was especially
convincing because it employed a cross over design.44 Forty-five couples
were randomized to receive either immediate varicocelectomy or delayed
varicocelectomy following one year of observation. Despite the fact that
a retroperitoneal, high ligation technique was used, pregnancy rates were
6 times higher in the men undergoing immediate varicocelectomy compared
to those in the observation group (60% vs. 10% respectively) over the
first year. Furthermore, pregnancy rates rose 4-fold in the observation
group during the first year after surgical correction.
Overall,
varicocelectomy results in significantly improved semen parameters in
60% to 80% of men and pregnancy rates of 20% to 60%. 45 One should keep
in mind, however, that most of the studies used to generate these figures
employed what the authors believe to be suboptimal varicocelectomy techniques.
Using the microscopic subinguinal approach, we have observed a 69% pregnancy
rate at two years postoperatively when female infertility factors were
excluded.46
As mentioned
previously, varicocelectomy can even be effective in men with azoospermia
or severe oligospermia. Matthews and Goldstein recently reported that
55% of azoospermic men and 69% of men with zero motile sperm before surgery
had motile sperm observed in their ejaculate after varicocele repair.47
Thirty-one percent of these otherwise sterile men contributed to pregnancies
leading to live births including 19% who did so without the help of assisted
reproduction. Steckel and co-workers found that men with large varicoceles
have poorer semen quality than men with small varicoceles.59 Fortunately,
the men with larger (Grade III) varicoceles also showed a greater degree
of improvement following varicocelectomy.
When discussing
varicocelectomy as a treatment for male infertility, it is again important
to remember that varicoceles cause a progressive decline in testicular
function (both spermatogenesis and steroidogenesis) with time.2 Thus,
for couples desiring more than one child, the ability of varicocelectomy
to prevent further deterioration may be even more important than the procedure's
early beneficial effects on semen quality.
Varicocelectomy
is indicated in adolescents when accompanied by ipsilateral testicular
atrophy. Studies on adult men with varicoceles have shown that the degree
of testicular atrophy is proportional to the clinical grade of the varicocele.48
Varicocele patients with testicular atrophy have worse semen parameters
than those without atrophy.49 Several studies have shown quite convincingly
that correction of adolescent varicocele results in rapid catch-up growth
of the affected testis.50,53 In addition, a recent study by Lenzi and
colleagues showed that adults who had varicoceles corrected during adolescence
had significantly better semen parameters than adults with varicoceles
detected during adolescence who did not have them repaired.54
Many men
with varicoceles often experience intermittent, mild discomfort in the
testis and scrotum on the affected side. The pain is usually described
as a dull, throbbing ache. On rare occasions, the pain caused by a varicocele
can become debilitating. After exhausting more conservative measures and
ruling out other etiologies, varicocele ligation may be the only treatment
alternative remaining. Peterson and colleagues recently reported on 35
patients who underwent varicocelectomy purely for the relief of pain.55
Eighty-six percent of the men experienced complete resolution of the pain
postoperatively. Unfortunately, 11% had either persistent or worsening
symptoms.
Cost -effectiveness
In the last decade, assisted reproductive techniques such as intracytoplasmic
sperm injection (ICSI) have revolutionized the treatment of male infertility.
The rising success rates and widespread availability of ICSI has led some
gynecologists and reproductive endocrinologists to "bypass"
both the evaluation and treatment of the male while proceeding straight
to assisted reproduction. This is unfortunate because many cases of male
infertility are caused by correctable conditions such as varicocele.
The managed
care era has ushered in a heightened awareness of cost effectiveness and
outcomes research. Schlegel recently performed a comparison of ICSI and
varicocelectomy for the treatment of varicocele-associated infertility
using a "cost per delivery" analysis.56 Total hospital delivery
costs, complication costs, and costs attributable to multiple gestations
were taken into account along with the published pregnancy and delivery
rates for the two procedures. The overall cost per delivery for varicocelectomy
averaged $26,300 compared to a striking $89,000 per delivery for ICSI
in 1994 U.S. dollars. The European experience is similar. Comhaire, et
al. has estimated that varicocelectomy is seven times more cost effective
than ICSI.57 Although ICSI can clearly facilitate pregnancies in couples
with varicocele-associated infertility, it is a very expensive alternative.
Summary
Varicoceles
are common. They may be detected in 15% of the male population, 35% of
men with primary infertility and up to 80% of men with secondary infertility.
Studies have shown that varicocele causes progressive duration-dependent
injury to the seminiferous epithelium and testicular function over time.
The most likely pathophysiologic mechanism is an elevation of testicular
temperature due to impaired scrotal thermoregulation. Varicocele repair
will halt this duration-dependent process.
The most
common complications from varicocelectomy are hydrocele, varicocele recurrence,
and testicular artery injury. Use of the operating microscope allows for
reliable identification of spermatic cord lymphatics, internal spermatic
veins and venous collateral, and the testicular artery or arteries so
that the incidence of these complications can be reduced significantly.
Delivery of the testis through a small subinguinal incision provides direct
visual access to all possible avenues of testicular drainage. Although
some controversy continues to surround varicocelectomy as a treatment
of male factor infertility, a great deal of data does exist to support
this form of therapy. Ultimately, a final answer will require a large,
prospective, randomized and controlled study using a microsurgical, artery
and lymphatic sparing technique.
Congenital Bilateral Absence of Vas Deferens
Congenital
bilateral absence of vas deferens (CBAVD)is diagnosed in 1.3 % of the
men referred for infertility evaluation. Moreover, CBAVD accounts for
27% of the men with primary obstructive azzospermia. An almost equal number
of men with other causes of surgically unreconstrucatable obstructuctive
azoospermia are referred for evaluation. In the past decade, the techniques
of epididymal sperm retrieval and micromanipulation to assist fertilization
have been two of the most exciting developments in the field of male infertility
treatment. Men with congenital bilateral absence of the vas defences (CBAVD),
or acquired reproductive tract obstruction are now able to achieve pregnancies
with use of these advanced techniques. We have found that microsurgical
epididymal sperm aspiration (MESA) using a glass micropipet technique
simultaneous to intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) appears to maximize
opportunities of pregnancy for these infertile couples with unreconstructable
male reproductive tract obstruction. MESA from individual epididymal tubules
with a micropuncture technique allows retrieval of high numbers of sperm
with optimal quality for immediate use during ICSI as well as for cryopreservation.
A unique micropuncture pipet holding apparatus, MESA- Holder has been
developed at Cornell. Its unique 180° angle adjustable pipet holding
system simplifies the procedure of micropuncture epididymal sperm retrieval.
The micropuncture technique is an atraumatic technique that limits damage
to the epididymal tubules and avoids potential blood cell contamination
of the epididymal fluid, while yielding high quantities of motile spermatozoa.
Experience with the last 59 couples with obstructive azoospermia who selected
to undergo MESA-ICSI at Cornell from April, 1995 to June, 1996 is presented.
Sperm was retrieved from the epididymis in 59/59 (100%) attempts, despite
multiple aliquots of previous unsuccessful sperm retrieval attempts at
other institutions. In all 59 cases motile sperm were cryopreserved as
well. Clinical pregnancies were achieved in 80%( 47/59) cycles for these
couples. Ongoing pregnancies or deliveries have occurred for in 68% (40/59)
cycles of simultaneous MESA-ICSI. .Simultaneous MESA-ICSI appears to provide
optimal pregnancy and delivery rates for couples where the man has unreconstructable
reproductive tract obstruction.
Ejaculatory
Duct Obstruction
Men with fructose-negative azoospermia, low semen volume, and at least
one palpable vas deferens have either a congenital vasal anomaly or obstruction
of the ejaculatory duct. Digital rectal examination may reveal a midline
cystic structure. Transrectal sonography has revolutionized the diagnosis
and treatment of ejaculatory duct obstruction. If a midline cystic lesion
or dilated ejaculatory ducts and seminal vesicles are visualized sonographically,
we may ask our sonographer to aspirate 2-3 cm of fluid and instill methylene
blue. The aspirate is examined microscopically and if sperm are found,
transurethral resection (TUR) of the ejaculatory duct is performed without
need for prior vasography as the presence of sperm indicates that at least
one side is not obstructed more proximally and that the cyst or dilated
ejaculatory duct communicates with a nonobstructed vas. The instillation
of methylene blue assists in localizing the opening of the ejaculatory
duct and confirms that resection has entered the system. Transrectal aspiration
should be performed immediately prior to anticipated surgery and should
employ the same bowel prep and antibiotic prophylaxis used for transrectal
prostate biopsy. If no sperm are found in the aspirate, vasography is
necessary. This is performed as previously described. If no sperm are
found in the vas, vasoepididymostomy is performed at the same sitting.
If ejaculatory duct obstruction is confirmed by vasography employing a
50% water-soluble contrast media, the umbilical artery catheters used
for vasography stents are left in place so that a dilute methylene blue
solution can be injected by the assistant during resection. The resectoscope,
with the 24-Fr cutting loop, is engaged with a finger placed in the rectum
providing anterior displacement of the posterior lobe of the prostate.
The ejaculatory ducts course between the bladder neck and the verumontanum
and exit at the level of and along the lateral aspect of the verumontanum.
Resection should be carried out in this region with great care taken to
preserve the bladder neck proximally, the striated sphincter distally,
and the rectal mucosa posteriorly, Efflux of methylene blue from dilated
orifices confirms adequate resection, Avoid excessive coagulation. If
formal vasography is performed, the hemivasotomies are closed employing
microsurgical technique. A Foley catheter is left overnight and the patient
should receive a 5- to 7-day course of antibiotics.
Electroejaculation
Men with neurologic impairments in their sympathetic outflow, as in traumatic
spinal cord injury (SCI), demyelinating neuropathies (multiple sclerosis),
diabetes, and following retroperitoneal lymph node dissection (often for
testis tumor), frequently have abnormalities or absence of seminal emission.
Electroejaculation (EEJ) has been proven to be a safe and effective means
to obtain motile sperm suitable for assisted reproductive techniques (intrauterine
insemination or in vitro fertilization).Electroejaculation (EEJ) is normally
performed under general anesthesia, though for men with a complete spinal
cord injury (SCI), anesthesia may not be necessary. To prevent autonomic
dysreflexia, men with SCI, particularly above the level of T-5, are premeditated
with 20mg of nifedipine, sublingually, 15 minutes prior to EEJ. The procedure
begins by first catheterizing the patient in supine position and emptying
the bladder completely. The use of Betadine and Surgilube is to be avoided
because of their spermicidal effect. Instead, the urethra is lubricated
with glycerin or, preferably, by instillation of 2 cc of 6% simulated
human tubal fluid and plasmanate. The pH of the urine should be assessed
to ensure its alkalinity (pH>6.5). Oral sodium bicarbonate may be used
if necessary. Because retrograde ejaculation (backwards ejaculation into
the bladder) occurs frequently in this procedure, an additional 10 cc
of the simulated human tubal fluid and plasmanate is instilled into the
bladder to help preserve any sperm inside the bladder. The catheter is
then removed. Although it is possible to perform the procedure in lithotomy
position, lateral decubitus position is preferred, as it allows easier
access to both the penis and rectum.The patient is put on his side with
his thighs and knees slightly flexed. All pressure points are appropriately
padded. A blood pressure cuff is applied to the patient's left arm for
continuous blood pressure monitoring every 2 minutes. Digital rectal examination
and anoscopy should be performed before and after the procedure to inspect
the rectal ampulla and mucosa for any injury. In patients with SCI, it
is not uncommon to find rectal mucosal abrasion, especially if they are
being managed with a chronic digital bowel program. If anoscopic inspection
is not performed prior to the EEJ, one could mistakenly attribute the
rectal abrasion to be caused by the procedure. After proper inspection,
a well-lubricated large rectal probe with horizontal electrode plates
is introduced gently into the rectal ampulla, and is stabilized against
the anterior rectal wall at the level of the seminal vesicles and prostate.
Electrostimulation via the rectal probe may then begin.The rectal probe
is connected to an adjustable output power source and is capable of simultaneously
recording the temperature of the probe through a thermistor. The amount
of current and voltage needed depends on the patient's body habitus and
the extent of his neurologic injury. In patients with incomplete SCI,
the procedure may be limited by their tolerance to pain, as sensation
may be present.Rhythmic delivery of current is performed by manually turning
the dial to increase the voltage delivery progressively for a few seconds.
After a few initial stimulation, the voltage is reduced to zero. Voltage
is then gradually increased until erection/ejaculation has occurred. The
voltage at which the first erection/ejaculation occurs is noted and is
then increased to a level 30% to 50% higher, depending on patient's tolerance
and the rectal temperature which is constantly monitored and displayed.
Ejaculation may be entirely retrograde. In these cases, sweating, piloerection,
" goose bumps" on the things and buttocks, and erection may
be the only signs that the patient is adequately stimulated and that ejaculation
has occurred. The number of stimulation, the current, and the voltage
necessary to produce a maximum erection are noted, as this information
will be useful for subsequent procedure if needed. The ejaculate is collected
directly into a cup containing 3 cc of human tubal fluid (HTF) buffer.The
probe temperatures as well as the number of stimulation required to achieve
full erection and ejaculation are recorded. The ejaculate is then collected
in a sterile wide-mouth plastic container. The numbers of stimulation
and maximum voltage required may vary and ejaculation may be retrograde.
If the probe temperature rises rapidly to above 40oC, we either change
the rectal probe or suspend the stimulation until the temperature falls
below 38oC.Following electroejaculation, anoscopy is performed again prior
to returning the patient in the supine position. The bladder is catheterized
to collect the post-ejaculate urine, which is sent along with the ejaculate
to the IVF laboratory for processing.Currently, employing this technique,
semen can be obtained in more than 90% of neurologically impaired men.
More than 40% of the couples achieve pregnancy with IUI or IVF. Pregnancy
rates are slightly better among couples in which the male partner had
SCI (43%) or idiopathic anejaculation (33%) then those who had undergone
retroperitoneal lymph node dissection (20%) or had diabetes (0%).
Specific
Medical Treatments
1. Infection
2. Antisperm Antibodies
3. Hypogonadotropic Hypogonadism
4. Normogonadotropic Hypogonadism
5. Retrograde Ejeculation
Infection
Semen cultures, urine cultures, and cultures of expressed prostatic secretions
are indicated in the presence of leukospermia. In patients who demonstrate
symptoms referable to the genitourinary tract or sperm agglutination,
cultures are obtained after the penis, scrotum, and perineum have been
cleansed with an antibacterial scrub as previously described. If cultures
are positive, treatment should employ an agent to which the cultured organism
is sensitive and that has no effect on spermatogenesis but good genitourinary
penetration. Antibiotics with such a profile include the fluoroquinolones
and tetracyclines. In the absence of a positive culture but with a high
clinical suspicion of infection we employ empiric fluoroquinolone or tetracycline
therapy for 3-6 weeks, treating both partners.
Antisperm
Antibodies
Our approach to the management of patients with antisperm antibodies is
to identify and treat the underlying problem, ie, repair the obstruction
or varicocele. If this is not successful, we initiate treatment with 20
mg of prednisone twice daily days 1-10 of the wives' cycle and 5 mg on
days 11 and 12 for 3 months. Following this treatment course we reevaluate
-for the presence of antibodies. Aseptic necrosis of the femoral head
is the most devastating complication of steroid therapy (1 % incidence),
although this is uncommon with short term (< 6 months), intermittent
(12 days/month) therapy. We now recommend IVF with ICSI which is very
successful for severe antibody problems.
Hypogonadotropic
Hypogonadism
This condition is due to the lack of the hypothalamic decapeptide gonadotropin-releasing
hormone (GnRH), When associated with midline defects such as anosmia,
it is called Kallmann's syndrome. Very low or undetectable serum levels
of LH, FSH and T in a prepubertal appearing adult confirms the diagnosis.
Treatment for the development of secondary sexual characteristics and
maintenance of libido is Depo-Testosterone. For induction of spermatogenesis,
the Depo-Testosterone is discontinued. Human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG)
1500 IU 3 times weekly is begun. After 3-6 months of hCG therapy, when
serum T,Ievels are in the normal range, human menopausal gonadotropin
(hMG) 25-75 IU 3 times weekly is added. Sperm usually begin to appear
in the ejaculate 6-18 months after initiation of therapy. Testis size
and sperm counts remain lower than normal, but pregnancies occur regularly
with sperm densities in the 2-6 million per mL range. Men who fail to
respond to gonadotropin replacement may respond to pulsatile administration
of GnRH by pump.
Normogonadotropic
Hypogonadism
These patients have low sperm counts and normal levels of FSH and LH,
but a low serum T. Before treatment, a prolaebou should be obtained to
rule out a pituitary tumor. In these men clomiphene citrate 25 mg daily
(1/2 tab) blocks the negative feedback inhibition of estrogen to the pituitary
increasing LH and FSH release and subsequently increasing serum T and
improving sperm densities. Semen parameters improve in 94% of men with
40% pregnancy rate achieved. Serum T, estradiol, and a semen analysis
are obtained every 3 months. Failure to respond may be attributable to
over- or understimulation. If posttreatment testosterone levels remain
low, increase the dose to 50 mg daily. If levels exceed 1000 ng/dL and/or
estradiol levels exceed 60 ng/L, reduce the dose by 50%. We have observed
nonbacterial pyospermia develop in 17% of previously nonpyospermic clomiphene
citrate-treated men. As no clomiphene-treated man who has developed pyospermia
has contributed to a pregnancy, we serially monitor semen analyses for
its development.
Retrograde
Ejaculation
Retrograde ejaculation is associated with a diminished volume or complete
lack of seminal emission, and is often the first symptom of diabetes mellitus.
The diagnosis may be confirmed by microscopic examination of a posteiaculation
urine specimen. Pseudoephedrine (Sudafed) 120 mg 3 times daily will convert
approximately 25% of men to antegrade ejaculation. Ejaculation with a
full bladder is sometimes helpful. A full bladder stimulates increased
a-adrenergic activity at the bladder neck. If these measures fail, the
urine may be alkalinzed and the sperm from the postejaculate urine retrieved,
processed, and used for IUI or IVF with ICSI.
|